- Home
- Countertops
- Products
- Gallery
- Customer Testimonials
- Design Simulator
- Resources
- Contact
Trying to choose between granite and quartz countertops? Learn the pros, cons, costs, and aesthetics of both to find the perfect fit for your Pittsburgh kitchen remodel.
Remodeling your kitchen involves many decisions, but one of the biggest is choosing the right countertop material. Two of the most popular types are granite and quartz, two premium surfaces that offer distinct benefits and unique looks.
If you’re planning a kitchen remodel with quartz or granite countertops in Pittsburgh or one of its surrounding suburbs, you’re likely trying to balance aesthetics, durability, cost, and ease of maintenance. With so many options available, it’s essential to get a clear, unbiased comparison.
Whether you’re aiming for a sleek, modern vibe or a warm, traditional style, both granite and quartz have something to offer. Let’s explore how each material performs in real-world kitchens, and which one might be the right fit for your lifestyle and design preferences.
Granite has long been a favorite for Pittsburgh homeowners who enjoy the look of natural stone. It’s prized for its one-of-a-kind patterns and long-lasting strength.
Granite is 100% natural stone, quarried from the earth and cut into slabs. After quarrying, the slabs are polished to a smooth, glossy finish that highlights their unique mineral patterns. Because each piece of granite is different, you’ll never find two countertops that look exactly alike.
Granite is known for its toughness. It’s heat-resistant—perfect for placing hot pots or pans without worry—and it resists scratches and chips under regular use. That said, it’s still stone, so it can chip at edges or corners if struck hard with a heavy object.
Granite is a porous material, so it needs to be sealed during installation and resealed periodically (usually once a year). This helps protect against staining from oil, wine, or other liquids. Daily cleaning is simple using mild soap and water—avoid harsh or acidic cleaners, which can wear down the sealant over time.
Granite stands out among homeowners who want natural character and organic patterns. Slabs are available in a wide range of earth tones, including browns, blacks, creams, and even blues and greens. The veining in the stone lends a timeless feel to any kitchen, especially in traditional or rustic homes.
Granite prices vary widely depending on the slab’s color, origin, and cut. The common patterns are often more affordable, while rare or exotic varieties can be more expensive. Installation costs also depend on the complexity of your kitchen layout and the thickness of the slab.
Quartz is an increasingly popular choice in Pittsburgh kitchens, especially among homeowners who want a modern, low-maintenance surface that still looks high-end.
Unlike granite, quartz countertops are engineered. They’re made from about 90–95% crushed natural quartz stone, combined with resins and pigments. This mix creates a solid, non-porous surface with a consistent appearance.
Quartz is incredibly durable—more so than granite in terms of impact resistance. It’s non-porous, which means it won’t absorb spills and is highly stain-resistant. It also resists scratches in daily use, though like any surface, it can still be damaged by excessive force.
Quartz doesn’t require sealing, which makes it a popular choice for busy households. It’s simple to clean with a damp cloth and gentle cleaner. There’s no need to worry about resealing or deep maintenance, making it a practical option for homeowners who want a beautiful look without the upkeep.
One of quartz’s biggest strengths is its visual consistency. Since it’s engineered, quartz can be made to mimic natural stone or present a more uniform appearance. This makes it ideal for modern, transitional, or minimalist designs where a cohesive color palette is preferred.
Colors range from solid whites and grays to more elaborate patterns that replicate marble or granite.
Quartz countertops are typically in the mid- to high-range, comparable to higher-end granite. Since quartz is manufactured, pricing is typically more consistent across color and pattern options, giving homeowners more predictability when budgeting.
To help you make an informed decision, let’s walk through the core differences between granite and quartz in six key areas:
Granite is a 100% natural stone that’s quarried, cut, and polished. Each slab is one-of-a-kind, offering variation in color, veining, and pattern. Quartz, on the other hand, is an engineered material made from about 90–95% crushed quartz stone mixed with resins and pigments. The result is a durable surface with a uniform appearance.
Both granite and quartz are considered highly durable materials for kitchen use, but they differ slightly in performance. Granite is heat-resistant and hard to scratch, making it excellent for cooking environments. Quartz is even more resistant to everyday impact and less likely to chip, though its resin content can be sensitive to extreme heat.
Granite needs a bit more attention to stay in peak condition. Because it’s porous, it must be sealed periodically to protect against stains. Quartz doesn’t require sealing at all. It’s non-porous by design so that spills won’t soak in, and cleanup is simple—wipe with a mild cleaner and water.
If you love natural movement, veining, and unpredictable patterns, granite offers plenty of visual interest. No two slabs are the same, which gives your kitchen a distinctive look. Quartz appeals to those who prefer consistency and control over color and pattern. It’s especially suited to minimalist or contemporary designs.
Granite handles high heat exceptionally well—allowing you to place hot pots and pans on the surface without concern. Quartz resists stains better due to its non-porous nature, but it’s not as heat-tolerant. Prolonged exposure to hot temperatures can cause discoloration or damage to the resins in quartz.
In terms of pricing, both granite and quartz fall into the mid to high range, depending on factors like brand, color, thickness, and edge design. Granite’s price can vary more widely based on rarity and source, while quartz typically has more stable pricing across product lines. More complex countertop installations, such as cutouts for sinks or custom edges, also affect the final cost for both materials.
Granite requires quarrying, which can have a greater environmental footprint, primarily if the stone is sourced from overseas. Quartz is manufactured, and some brands incorporate recycled materials like glass or pre-used stone. If sustainability is a concern of yours, ask our team about locally sourced granite or eco-conscious quartz options.
Choosing between granite and quartz isn’t just about looks; it’s about how you use your kitchen. Here are some scenarios to help guide your decision:
Quartz might be the better fit. It’s non-porous, doesn’t need sealing, and resists stains from juice, wine, and other spills. This makes it a low-maintenance option for families who cook often or entertain guests.
Granite handles high heat better than quartz, making it ideal for those who regularly work with hot pans or use countertop appliances. However, be cautious with heavy cookware near the edges of the countertop, as even granite can chip under impact.
Quartz offers a clean, uniform look that’s great for sleek, modern kitchens. It’s also the easier route if you’re aiming for symmetry or want multiple counters to match precisely.
Granite is a true natural product. If you love the idea of each slab being unique, granite gives your kitchen a character and depth that only nature can create.
Some quartz brands incorporate recycled glass or stone, reducing environmental impact. However, because quartz is engineered, it requires petroleum-based resins. Granite requires quarrying, which can affect natural landscapes.
If eco-friendliness is important to you, ask your countertop supplier about the sourcing and sustainability certifications of each material.
Trends in the Pittsburgh area reflect national shifts, with quartz gaining popularity due to its practicality and design flexibility. In newer homes and kitchen remodels, especially in areas like Wexford, South Hills, and Cranberry Township, quartz is often selected for its sleek appeal and low maintenance needs.
However, granite continues to be a top choice for homeowners in older or traditional-style homes in neighborhoods like Mt. Lebanon, Squirrel Hill, and Fox Chapel. These homes often benefit from natural stone’s organic patterns and timeless appeal.
A recent kitchen remodel in Upper St. Clair, for example, incorporated
black granite on the island to contrast white cabinetry, offering a classic-yet-contemporary aesthetic. Meanwhile, a family in Robinson Township chose white quartz with subtle veining to achieve a bright, modern feel without sacrificing durability.
No matter which material you choose, the quality of the installation can make all the difference.
Granite and quartz countertops require careful templating, cutting, and fitting. Precise measurements ensure that seams are minimal and that the counters fit perfectly around sinks, cooktops, and corners. For granite, sealing must be done correctly to preserve its longevity. For quartz, clean, accurate cuts preserve the engineered look.
At Lexmar USA, we specialize in professional granite and quartz kitchen countertop installation in Pittsburgh. Our experienced team of installers handles every step, from consultation to final polish, ensuring your new surface not only looks beautiful but performs reliably for years to come.
We understand the nuances of each material and provide tailored recommendations based on your design preferences, cooking habits, and budget.
Granite and quartz each offer excellent benefits, and both can elevate the style and function of your kitchen. The choice really depends on your priorities:
Before you decide, consider visiting a local showroom to see full slabs in person. Feeling the texture, viewing the patterns, and talking to a knowledgeable professional can help make your decision much easier.
Contact Lexmar USA for expert granite and quartz countertop installation in Pittsburgh. Whether you’re remodeling an older home or designing your dream kitchen from scratch, we’re here to help you find the perfect fit.
Lexmar USA refers its customers to the following quality lender for their financing.
Click here for more details and enter Promo Code: 0038-3729